Disclaimer: The title is a little misleading. I support Israel's right to exist. I don't support all of their policies or politics.
The reason the subject of Israel is such a polarizing one to
we bystanders in America and other countries not intimately involved in the
matter is because of the intractability of the firebrands on both sides of the
issue. This is furthermore complicated
by the sheep that blindly follow one or the other sides of the discussion
without so much as clear, critical thinking on the matter.
Why?
Why is it so polarizing?
Here’s my theory. Zionism had
been a political movement well before the Second World War. It is a secular movement loosely based upon
the covenant God made with Abraham as outlined in Genesis. God promised Abraham that the land roughly
encompassing the modern state of Israel would belong to Abraham and His descendants forever.
Following the Holocaust, liberal reactionaries who were
incapable of seeing the third and fourth order effects caved to the Zionists in
their massive guilt for the fact that the Holocaust happened. Indeed it did happen simply because liberals
like Chamberlain did not have the intestinal fortitude to stand up to pure
evil. So, the modern state of Israel was
mandated by fiat of the United Nations in 1948.
And we all know the history following that. Liberal idealists created the state of
Israel.
When the Cold war began, just as in every other segment of
the world, an us versus them polarization took place. Israel naturally looked to the United States
as effectively its creator and protector from the expected backlash of the
Arabs and Palestinians revolting against Western interference. Once again, America was polarized by
political figures to divide people into two camps. The truly Marxist, anti-American left of the
hippy generation exemplified in the Weather Underground, the Students for a
‘Democratic’ Society amongst others used the useful idiots of the Palestinian
peoples as their cause célèbre to promote their ideological agenda. The political Zionists naturally moved from
the Truman and Kennedy Democrats to a new, uneasy alliance with the Country Club
Republicans of Nixon, Ford, and Rockefeller.
Again, throughout Reagan’s time, rather than supporting truly oppressed
peoples in Poland and other blocks of Soviet dominated parts of the world, the
political left continued to use the Palestinians as examples of the supposed
oppressive nature of ‘capitalism’ and ‘imperialism,’ conveniently forgetting
that their own political patrons of their fathers generations created the
manufactured modern state of Israel.
When the Cold War ended, the ideological blocks remained
affiliated with their political sponsors.
True, some Democrats remained solidly pro-Israel (Lieberman) and some
Republicans remained traditional Conservative (Buchanan, Ron Paul) and were
very anti-Israel.
How to Deal with It:
Most of this story is very well known. The problem today is that no one wishes to
deal with it in an adult manner.
Unfortunately that is especially concerning the so-called leaders of the
Palestinian peoples. Was the creation of
Israel a mistake? I think so. Did Palestinian people get forcibly removed
from their land? Absolutely. What’s the solution? It’s over sixty years since Israel’s
creation. Is it ‘fair’ to place people
back on their fathers’ or grandfathers’ land that the would-be new occupants
have no experience or knowledge of? I
don’t know. Is it fair for the United
States of America to deport the millions of Californians and Texans from the
former Mexican soil? Is it fair for
Germany and Russia to remove their people to make room for an entire small
nation of Jews to resettle them in Central Europe?
The problems here are self-evident. The solutions are not. Like the question of Amnesty in the United
States, there is no easy answer. There
is only compromise. The problem is that
HAMAS and Fatah have zero desire to compromise.
They do not want a permanent solution to this issue. To do so would mean a loss in their political
power. So long as there remains an
‘oppressed minority’ they have their power.
Similarly, so long as ‘racism’ is ‘rampant’ in America, the race pimps
of Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton will have power… and donations.
Oh, and I don’t support Israel because of the kooks on the
right either. I don’t believe they
remain God’s chosen people as a literal fact throughout the entire continuum of
the human experience on earth. God
created a new covenant with His people due to the inability of the Jewish
people to keep their covenant with God.
This covenant is now based upon grace and forgiveness through
Christ. So, no, I do not hold to people
like Beck and Haggee who believe Christ will return to restore the physical
nation of Israel.
I support Israel because I do not wish to see the stated
goals of HAMAS of the destruction of Israel and the slaughter of her
people. I support Israel because they
are a nation founded on the rule of law… which is a far cry from a ‘democratic’
election in Gaza. When there is no rule
of law, there is no protection of individuals and rights.
Of course Israel has to change and has to come to a
meaningful and lasting conclusion. But
when you are threatened with your very physical existence, you have to take
steps to protect yourself. When you make
concessions that net you nothing except closer rocket bases from which HAMAS
can shell your cities (the return of Gaza), you learn not to trust your fellow
‘brokers of the peace.’
What’s the solution?
I believe nothing meaningful will happen unless power brokers like
Jordan (who have oppressed the millions of Palestinian refugees in their
borders as long as Israel has) and Saudi Arabia hold the leaders of the
Palestinians to their word and to their agreements. Only when the Western nations can hold Israel
to its concessions and when Arab leaders stop using Israel as the ultimate
straw-man with which to maintain their power and hold the Palestinians to their
word, can there be a lasting peace and a lasting solution.
But, the firebrands throwing the word Nazi around will not
bring that change.
No comments:
Post a Comment